How we mark exams
Assessment in our graded exams for instruments and singing is based on our marking criteria. You can also find these in our printed syllabus booklets.
The marking criteria show what we expect for the three levels of pass – Pass, Merit and Distinction – in each element of the exam. They are designed to maximise consistency in our marking and to make our approach to assessment clear for everyone.
Understanding how our examiners award marks is not only helpful for exam preparation but also for learning and progression generally.
If you know what the ingredients of a good performance are then you also know what to work on to reach this goal.
Pieces and songs
The marking criteria cover the different aspects of playing or singing under five areas: pitch; time; tone; shape and performance. These can be applied to all instruments, including voice, and all types of piece or song. The marking criteria show what our examiners listen for under each of these headings.
- Pitch – accuracy, clarity, reliability of notes and/or intonation.
- Time – suitability of tempo, stability of pulse, sense of rhythm.
- Tone – control and projection of sound, sensitivity and awareness in use of tonal qualities.
- Shape – effectiveness and clarity of musical shaping and detailing.
- Performance – overall command of the instrument or voice, involvement with the music, musical communication.
Marking criteria for pieces
Grades 1-8
|
Mark |
Pitch |
Time |
Tone |
Shape |
Performance |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Distinction |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Merit |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Pass |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Below Pass |
|
|
|
|
|
|
13-16 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
10-12 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
0 |
|
|
|
|
|
Other exam elements
The marking criteria also show what examiners listen for in the other elements of our exams:
-
Grades 1-8
Accuracy of notes/pitch, rhythmic continuity and fluency, tone and shaping, security and confidence of the response.
Mark
Scales and arpeggios
Distinction
19–21- Highly accurate notes/pitch
- Fluent and rhythmic
- Musically shaped
- Confident response
Merit
17–18- Largely accurate notes/pitch
- Mostly regular flow
- Mainly even tone
- Secure response
Pass
14-16- Generally correct notes/pitch, despite errors
- Continuity generally maintained
- Generally reliable tone
- Cautious response
Below Pass
11-13- Frequent errors in notes and/or pitch
- Lacking continuity and/or some items incomplete
- Unreliable tone
- Uncertain response and/or some items not attempted
7-10
- Very approximate notes and/or pitch
- Sporadic and/or frequently incomplete
- Serious lack of tonal control
- Very uncertain response and/or several items not attempted
0
- No work offered
* Includes Transposition for Horn, Trumpet and Organ (Grades 6–8) and Figured bass realization for Harpsichord (Grades 4–8).
In these cases, of the total 21 marks, 12 are allocated to Sight-reading and 9 to Transposition (or Figured bass realization), and one combined mark is recorded.
-
Grades 1-8
Control of pitch and intonation, sense of rhythmic character, use of vocal qualities, effectiveness of musical shaping, quality of musical involvement, communication and storytelling.
Mark
Unaccompanied traditional song
Distinction
19–21- Excellent control of pitch and intonation
- Rhythmic character well conveyed
- Sensitive use of vocal qualities
- Expressive, idiomatic musical shaping
- Fully committed communication, vivid story-telling
Merit
17–18- Good control of pitch and intonation
- Rhythmic character conveyed
- Good use of vocal qualities
- Clear musical shaping
- Good musical involvement and story-telling
Pass
14-16- Generally reliable control of pitch and intonation
- Adequate sense of rhythmic character
- Sufficient use of vocal qualities
- Some musical shaping
- Some musical involvement and story-telling
Below Pass
11-13- Unreliable control of pitch and/or intonation
- Inadequate sense of rhythmic character
- Insufficient use of vocal qualities
- Lack of musical shaping
- Insufficient musical involvement and/or story-telling
7-10
- Very unreliable control of pitch and/or intonation
- Lacking rhythmic character
- No use of vocal qualities
- No musical shaping
- Lacking musical involvement and/or story-telling
0
- No work offered
-
Grades 1-8
Rhythmic accuracy, continuity, accuracy of notes, pitch and key, realisation of musical detail, level of confidence in presentation.
Mark
Sight-reading*
Distinction
19–21- Fluent, rhythmically accurate
- Accurate notes/pitch/key
- Musical detail realised
- Confident presentation
Merit
17–18- Adequate tempo, usually steady pulse
- Mainly correct rhythm
- Largely correct notes/pitch/key
- Largely secure presentation
Pass
14-16- Continuity generally maintained
- Note values mostly realised
- Pitch outlines in place, despite errors
- Cautious presentation
Below Pass
11-13- Lacking overall continuity
- Incorrect note values
- Very approximate notes/pitch/key
- Insecure presentation
7-10
- No continuity or incomplete
- Note values unrealised
- Pitch outlines absent
- Very uncertain presentation
0
- No work offered
* Includes Transposition for Horn, Trumpet and Organ (Grades 6–8) and Figured bass realization for Harpsichord (Grades 4–8).
In these cases, of the total 21 marks, 12 are allocated to Sight-reading and 9 to Transposition (or Figured bass realization), and one combined mark is recorded.
-
Grades 1-8
Accuracy, musical perception and awareness, security of responses.
Mark
Aural tests
Distinction
17–18- Accurate throughout
- Musically perceptive
- Confident response
Merit
15–16- Strengths significantly outweigh weaknesses
- Musically aware
- Secure response
Pass
12-14- Strengths just outweigh weaknesses
- Cautious response
Below Pass
9-11- Weaknesses outweigh strengths
- Uncertain response
6-8
- Inaccuracy throughout
- Vague response
0
- No work offered
Awarding marks
Examiners mark each candidate based on what they hear in the exam room. We do not have quotas, so our examiners do not pass or fail a certain percentage of candidates.
When awarding marks examiners assess the candidate’s control of the qualities and skills listed in the marking criteria. Candidates do not need to meet all the criteria to pass their exam as weakness in some areas is often balanced by stronger achievement in others.
The total number of marks available in an exam is 150. Candidates need:
- 100 marks to Pass;
- 120 marks to pass with Merit;
- 130 marks to pass with Distinction.
The total number of marks available for each exam element are listed here:
| Grades 1 to 8 |
|---|---|
Piece / Song 1 | 30 |
Piece / Song 2 | 30 |
Piece / Song 3 | 30 |
Song 4 | -- |
Scales and arpeggios | 21 |
Sight-reading* / sight-singing | 21 |
Aural tests | 18 |
*Includes a transposition test for Horn, Trumpet and Organ at Grades 6 to 8 and a figured-bass realisation test for Harpsichord
Examiners mark up or down from the pass mark in every section, rather than taking marks away from the maximum or adding them from zero.
For each element of the exam, candidates need to achieve two-thirds of the total possible marks to pass, but they don’t need to pass all elements to achieve an overall pass in the exam.